Struggling to move past my (very) Haram relationship
Assalamu Alaikum. I’m a 17 year old guy living in the US, and as the title suggests, I’m struggling to move past my Haram relationship. I’d honestly consider it to be way more Haram than it should’ve ever been.
It all started in 2024. I had been in 2 Haram relationships before, one as a freshman in HS and one as a sophomore. The first one blew up because I just found her boring after a little while. The second one ended because the girl was a closeted lesbian who had feelings for girls instead of me. The fallout of the second relationship really shook me, so I turned my life to contribute to 3 goals: God, Grades, and Gains.
And honestly, that worked really good! I was gaining muscle, I was top 10% of my class, and I went for Umrah. Alhamdulillah. Life kept getting better, I was elected president of my entire student body, I got an amazing first job as a computer science teacher with a kids coding center, and I personally felt “high on life” if that’s what you wanna call it. I had no interest in Haram relationships anymore.
Then came October 2025. I met this beautiful atheist girl, let’s call her C. C was a year younger than me, friends with my second ex, really good friends with me. She actually rejected me in 2024 because she heard from someone that I was going to convert her to Islam by force if she got with me. But she and I reconnected at our school’s homecoming dance. We danced, and there hasn’t been a day since then where we haven’t spoken.
During the buildup of our talking stage, I kept contemplating if I wanted to start this with her or not. If I wanted to violate the sanctity of my life. I kept hinting to her that I was attracted but uninterested. But she never got the hint, and at some point, I just wanted to be with her regardless of consequence.
My parents knew about my past 2 relationships and told me if I got in another one they would take away my college fund. This did not matter to me when I asked C to be my girlfriend.
Our relationship was perfect for the first month, but things started going wrong in December. December was when this relationship led to doing the action nobody should do until marriage. I felt myself slipping. My grades temporarily dropped, and while they turned into As again, I felt less “whole” as a person.
The intimacy didn’t really stop though. As it kept going, I spiraled more. Ramadan was the only break we had, and even during this, my urges were so high that I was more focused on her than on becoming a better Muslim. But after the month ended and we got back together, I didn’t feel as connected to her as before.
In April, I got busy with university-level research projects, and she got busy with studying Christianity, a religion C didn’t practice. At some point, she started saying stuff like “if we get married, our kids should practice both religions.” “I don’t have an interest in Islam anymore.” and other things that deeply worried me. This is when things stopped feeling right, so we broke up. But the pain I felt was too much, so after a literal day, we got back together. Even though I knew then that this could never result in marriage.
There were continuous ups and downs between May and July. There was continuous intimacy between May and July. But in August, I started doing things that violated her trust. I was spending time with female friends that she wasn’t comfortable with, I was allowing other people to talk bad about her, and I stopped doing as much for her. I stopped getting her flowers, stopped responding first, stopped caring in general. We were about to break up again, but we decided to try harder.
But at some point, I stopped really having a desire to talk to her. I still found her very attractive, I still found her sweet and kind, but I didn’t care about what she had to say anymore. I didn’t care about sharing my passwords with her anymore. I didn’t find any joy in the relationship. Then, I got caught up in college applications. After I got accepted into a competitive university (Alhamdullillah), I realized she and I had no trajectory overlap at all.
For the past few weeks, I have felt no desire to be with her anymore. Even playing video games with her felt boring. I didn’t want any of this, until today. I even did du’a that Allah SWT would remove me from this. Today, out of nowhere, I felt really good about us, and I wanted to rebuild our relationship. I was on call with her and she and I had a good conversation going and I felt in love again.
Until my bluetooth went from my car’s AUX to my dad’s car. And he heard C ask me a really sexual question and immediately connected the dots. And he told me to tell him everything.
I told him. I told him how I had been slipping in school because of this, how I skipped jummah sometimes to spend time with her, how I spent most of my time during Ramadan feeling desire towards her, how I had even had a pregnancy scare with her.
Baba wasn’t upset, he was worried. He was relieved to hear that no pregnancy had occurred, how things had gone good for as long as they did, and that I wasn’t hurt. Before making me cut off all contact with C, he reminded me, that if Allah SWT made His creation in pairs, then not even time, distance or wealth can separate them. That if C is my naseeb, a year will come where the gap is closed. But 2026 and 2027 are not those years.
I knew this was coming. I knew that I would be found out at some point. I realized this is why Haram relationships are Haram, why the Quran commands against Zina, and how wrong I have been. This is the best thing that could have happened honestly.
That doesn’t change how sad I feel about it though.
I have found myself at 2 AM, unable to sleep, shivering, and sad. I miss my C so much. I miss her warmth, her love, her voice. I cannot get over her and I thought if we removed a Haram from our lives it would be made easy for us. I genuinely cannot function and I’m feeling the consequences of this haram relationship. I have a college physics exam in 2 days and I’m more focused on grieving the loss of a one year relationship that wasn’t right for me. I dont know how to move forward from this and I’m worried I’m going to go back to her like how I did in April. I cannot afford this. I need Allah in my life again, not her, but I dont know how to convince my mind and body of that.
Thank you for submitting your post to Stones to Bridges! We pray you will find the responses below beneficial. If you find these responses helpful, we’d love for you to share what you appreciated and how you feel it might help you moving forward in the comments section below!
Response from a “Fatima Counselor”:
Salaam,
Thank you for your heartfelt message and your honesty. Intimate relationships are not easy to navigate and can lead to a lot of complications, as you’ve had with the pregnancy scare and all the heavy emotions from 3 different relationships. It’s a blessing that your father helped you put a stop to this, with compassion and wisdom.
Sex outside of marriage brings all kinds of risks. Aside from the emotional turbulence, with multiple sexual partners there’s a high risk of contracting sexually transmitted diseases – no matter how careful you think you are. You are not mentally, emotionally, or financially ready to deal with all of these potential consequences. Your father has offered you good advice: when you are mature and ready to responsibly handle adult life, then you can consider if C is the right life partner. Meanwhile, God, grades and gains can be a good short-term plan for living life. “Gains” should be healthy, wholesome, and balanced.
Is your life balanced? It sounds like you are investing time in academics and socializing, good. But our deen is a whole way of life. Do you exercise? Do you do something selfless for others? Gain should not be just personal gain, but rather, it should be for the greater good. So each day, can you spend a little time focusing on something selfless? As you expand your heart and mind, you may notice that you will think less about girls, and be able to better manage sexual frustration.
To control your body and mind, you need to give control to your spirit (Ruh). This means, changing from the inside. Think about what that means. Yes, you can still enjoy life and have fun at 17, but in a balanced way, with a focus on GOOD. Then “haram” wont flow so easily from you. Your spirit is pure and good.
Sincerely,
“Fatima FL”
Note from Admin: If you would like us to help you find a Muslim therapist/counselor in your area, please complete the Contact Us form at the footer of the website.
Disclaimer: If this is an emergency or involves potential harm to yourself or others, please call 911 or the National Suicide Prevention Helpline at 1-800-273-TALK(8255). Any information on this website is not a substitute for and does not replace the advice from mental health or medical professionals. Click here to read our full Disclaimer.
Here are some additional posts on this topic that you may find helpful: https://www.stonestobridges.org/2024/12/15/sexual-desires/ https://www.stonestobridges.org/2024/06/28/i-need-advice/ https://www.stonestobridges.org/2025/08/25/i-dont-know-what-to-do/ https://www.stonestobridges.org/2026/08/09/i-need-help/ https://www.stonestobridges.org/2026/09/13/dating-a-catholic-as-a-muslim-and-broke-up/ https://www.stonestobridges.org/2025/07/19/haram-relationship-with-a-non-practicing-christian-man/



Peer Support Volunteer NL
Wa alaykum assalam, dear brother,
I really wanted to acknowledge how brave it is of you to seek help about your situation, and reading through your post, I can see how your heart is still connected to your Loving and Nurturing Rabb. Masha’Allah, may Allah reward you for your effort and striving to become closer to Him, ameen!
You mentioned feeling sad. It is sad. It is also hard, difficult, lonely and many other emotions that you are likely feeling. This does not mean that it will stay this way.
You’re 17 and still figuring your life out. The girl you were with is 16, and as teenagers, you are both figuring out who you are and what your place in this world is. The intensity that you felt in your relationship as a 16- to 17-year-old may have felt real, but how stable would it be?
You mentioned not being able to envision a future where the two of you are married, and this is an important observation. How you are now at 17 will likely not be how you will be at 27 (insha’Allah). As you age and your values and beliefs deepen (insha’Allah), you may wish to find company who share these same values and beliefs as you. Already you have mentioned drifting away from her as your values and belief systems are different. This would likely only increase with age unless one of you decides to change your values/beliefs.
Reading your post I can see how despite all of the emotions and everything you are experiencing, that connection you have to Allah is still there. You want to be close to Allah. This love that you have for Allah is not shared by the girl you were with, and as a believer in Allah, His Messenger, and in Islam, you deserve to be with people who also share this love.
Remember, brother, this beautiful narration from our Messenger (peace be upon him)
“Verily, you will never leave anything for the sake of Allah Almighty but that Allah will replace it with something better for you.”
You do not know if, by leaving this haram relationship, Allah will give you something better in return. What is better is not limited to having another person as comfort. Allah’s favour to us cannot be limited. Even just becoming closer to Him and having that peace in your heart that, no matter what, Allah is taking care of you and your situation is an invaluable source of comfort. Alhamduillah, you have your father with you to advise and counsel you through this difficult time. May Allah strengthen your relationship with him and keep you two close.
No tough times last forever, and with Allah’s help and permission, you will get through this. The best of Allah’s slaves are those who make mistakes and come back to Him.
May Allah bless you with the best of this life and the next and grant you the ability to achieve the highest ranks of Jannah, ameen!
All the Best,
Your Sister in Faith,
Peer Support Volunteer NL